Annotated Bib Peer Review

Don't write here. This is my page. Start your own.


  • Start a new page on your Name Page titled Annotated Bib Peer Review followed by your name.
  • Select 2 of your entries from your annotated bib that you are proud of, have questions about, or feel represent your work in general. Copy and paste those entries to your new Annotated Bib Peer Review page.
  • At the top of your Annotated Bib Peer Review page, write 1 or 2 questions you have for your reviewers. Leave space for them to answer.
  • Then, copy and paste the following questions (don't go into edit mode to do this — you will all lock each other out. Do it from the 'outside' of the page):
    • Are the summaries detailed enough that you understand what the source is all about? Are there details that the writer included that are unnecessary to the summary? What questions are you left with after reading the summaries?
    • Did the reviewer evaluate the sources using the CRAAP test? Do you see criteria based judgements about each letter (currency, relevance,authority, accuracy, purpose)? What is missing?
    • Are the reflection sections complete enough that you understand how the writer responded to the sources? Could they include more information?
    • Based on these two entries, in what direction do you think the writer's research is going?
    • What questions are you left with after reading these entries?
    • What are these annotations weaknesses?
    • What are these annotations strengths?

Then, in groups of three, evaluate two other writer's work. The best way to do this is to leave your Annotated Bib Peer Review page up on your computer and move to different computers to review. Go into edit mode on the writer's page and type your responses right in their page, followed by your first name. The nest reviewer can follow and type in their responses right after yours. You get credit for having your work reviewed, as well as reviewing the work of others. Help each other out.

Unless otherwise stated, the content of this page is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License