Annotated Bibliography Peer Review Belina

Are the summaries detailed enough that you understand what the source is all about? Are there details that the writer included that are unnecessary to the summary? What questions are you left with after reading the summaries?

Noelle:I feel like you did a very good job with your summaries. You were precise and provided necessary information without rambling.
Luke The summaries seemed to be pretty on point, very thorough and well thought out. No questions were in my head after reading the summaries.

Did the reviewer evaluate the sources using the CRAAP test? Do you see criteria based judgements about each letter (currency, relevance, authority, accuracy, purpose)? What is missing?

Noelle:It is easy to see that you applied the CRAAP tests while reviewing your sources. I believe you reviewed all the parts of the CRAAP test, leaving nothing out.
Luke Looked good to me, seemed like you hit all the points on the CRAPP test!

Are the reflection sections complete enough that you understand how the writer responded to the sources? Could they include more information?

Noelle:It was clear to see how you felt about the sources and which ones you were confident about using for research.
Luke The reflection was very clear to me, i understood how he responded and he did it well! I think the information written was more then enough.

Based on these three entries, in what direction do you think the writer's research is going?

Noelle:I think you are headed in the right direction. You know your opinion well, know how to analyze sources, and know which ones to use.
Luke seems like you know the way your headed and it seems to be the right direction. The research looks great!

What questions are you left with after reading these entries?

Luke None.

What are these annotations weaknesses?

Noelle:I found one error in the second annotation. In the first line you don't need an a before the word written. Also, maybe reread the last annotation, it didn't flow as smoothly as the first two.
Luke I had a hard time finding a big error, maybe just some of your grammar is off a little, some run ons, and some sections where it didnt flow as good as others.

What are these annotations strengths?

Noelle:Very thorough summaries and CRAAP tests.
Luke The summaries were easy to read and seemed the strongest.

I feel like I was vague on the summaries.
Noelle:I believe your summaries were quite thorough, and contained all the needed information.

Unless otherwise stated, the content of this page is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License